Wednesday, April 1, 2009

Pigs and Lobsters

While in Mexico visiting family a couple of summers ago, I was taken to many interesting places. We didn’t go to classic tourists areas like Cancun or Acapulco. Instead we stayed in Morelia, the capital of Michoacán, and later the quiet town of Nocupetaro. Here, life was very different from what I was use to. I met many relatives whose way of life was completely different from mine. One of the events that stick out from this trip happened in this town. They decided to cook pork that night, and in order to get they had to kill one of their pigs. It was a young pig, and in order to do this they chase it and hold it down while some one drives a knife through its armpit into its chest. Then it’s cleaned with boiling water, skinned and butchered. As I was watching this I was amazed at how none of this seemed out of the ordinary for them. I realized that this is their way of life, and if they want to eat, this is what they have to do. In relation to Consider the Lobster, I feel as if critics of lobster eating or boiling should realize that people don’t boil them simply to boil them and watch them squirm. It is simply a means to an end. And while I personally couldn’t stand to watch it, I understand that it is essentially a necessary evil. We must eat, and in order for us to eat animals must die. The logic can’t be denied or called barbaric because it is the basis of nature.

2 comments:

  1. I agree with you although I think you are missing the basis of what we debated in class. What we were debating wasn't so much on whether or not we should kill the pig or lobster but more on a question on how. I know that in the Jewish community, for a meat to be considered Kosher means that the animal was killed in the most humane way possibly in order to decrease the pain and fear felt by the animal. I think that our community is more sensitive to seeing animals killed because we are not used to seeing it whereas the people in Mexico might see it everyday and are therefore desensitized towards the killing. In conclusion, I agree that it is a means to an end but I also believe that those "means" should be in the most respectful way possible.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I see what your saying, and I do agree with it, that we shouldnt torture an animal, even if we plan on cooking and eating it. But I just think that that mentality is dangerous because it could snowball into other frivolous arguements about animal rights and ways to "humanely" kill them.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.